Culinarily speaking, there is nothing special about the meal you'll get from an old school style New York steakhouse. Most if not all offer the usual creamed spinach, iceburg lettuce salads, fried potato products and of course large quantities of meat.
The Palm is no different, a filet mignon the size of a softball was served perfectly medium rare. My aged NY strip (photo unavailable) ordered charred, medium rare was also cooked to perfection. The charring process added a nice crispy layer and well, charred taste to the meat. The meat of course was top quality, nicely trimmed and dry-aged which adds a nice a nice flavor and crispy texture to an already delicious cut of meat.
Getting back to the starters, the hearts of palm salad was nothing special, just the traditional luttuce, tomatos, black olives and boiled eggs you see on thousands of other salads not worth talking about.
The jumbo lump crabmeat cocktail was also good, the pieces were actually quite jumbo, but again very basic presentation, and a traditional cocktail sauce with plenty of horseradish.
And how about that half and half, apparently a favorite and a tradition at the Palm. The largest plate of fried onions and potatos I have ever seen. Unfortunately the potatoes were more chips than fries, and I would have preferred fries instead of chips with my steak.
Lobster bisque was not the best nor was it the worst. Creamy but not creamy, slightly bland and really nothing else worth mentioning. I still have fond memories of the bisque at the Lobster in Santa Monica, but that was usually accompanied by several bloody marys.
While on the subject of lobsters, I should point out that the Palm offers an incredibly tasty looking version of Pinchy for $22/lb. We were informed that most of the lobsters that night were about 4 lbs. I guess my problem with ordering an $88 lobster is that at least 3 lbs of it end up in the trash. Needless to say we didn't order any lobster. Nor did we try any of the old school Italian cooking.
We chose a bottle of the 2001 Stag's Leap merlot. This is available from stagsleap directly for $31/bottle. The Palm charges $60 for it, and it was in the bottom third of the wine list. Please bring your expense account clients to fully enjoy the wine list.
I actually almost forgot about the desserts. I'm not much of a key lime pie fan, but I'll admit the key lime at the Palm was terrific. The crust was firm and had that freshly baked crunch to it unlike so many others that have sat in restaurants for days. The creme brulee was also very good. Creamy, not creamy, sweet not sweet, and the brulee was nicely crisped.
As suspected we blew through our $200 gift card well before dessert and the bill pretty much looked like my car payment. And that's the biggest problem I have with places like this. While they do make sure to serve only the best cuts of meat, there is nothing special in the preperation. Figure about $20/lb at a quality butcher store for dry-aged steaks, $30 for the wine, you begin to wonder where that car payment went.